TextMaker better than OpenOffice for ODT compliance ?

Post bug reports and suggestions for TextMaker 2010 for Linux.

Moderator: SoftMaker Team

ArnaudK
Posts: 77
Joined: Thu Aug 19, 2010 6:37 pm

TextMaker better than OpenOffice for ODT compliance ?

Postby ArnaudK » Fri Aug 27, 2010 11:09 am

In ran few tests comparing ODT compatibility between OpenOffice and TextMaker and the results seem to indicate TextMaker is a little bit more compliant than OpenOffice Writer for ODT validation.

For that test I used the validator below :
http://tools.odftoolkit.org/odfvalidator/

I tested this file :
http://product.thinkfree.com/templates/rhuk_milkyway/images/screenshot/compatibility/write/03_layout.doc

When converting it from OpenOffice, I get the following errors :
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt/styles.xml[2,13051]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:layout-grid-snap-to-characters"
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt/content.xml[2,2728]:Error:attribute "style:page-number" has a bad value. Possible values are: auto, and more
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt/content.xml[2,3304]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt/content.xml[2,4186]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt/content.xml[2,5074]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt:Info:validation errors found
upload:///03_layout_toto.odt:Info:Generator: OpenOffice.org/3.2$Win32 OpenOffice.org_project/320m18$Build-9502


The file is valid when saved from Text Maker

For this file :
http://product.thinkfree.com/templates/rhuk_milkyway/images/screenshot/compatibility/write/23_ebXML%20System%20Overview.docx

From OpenOffice :
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview.odt/content.xml[2,13294]:Error:attribute "text:anchor-page-number" has a bad value: "0" does not satisfy the "positiveInteger" type
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview.odt:Info:validation errors found
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview.odt:Info:Generator: OpenOffice.org/3.2$Win32 OpenOffice.org_project/320m18$Build-9502


From TextMaker :
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/styles.xml[2,3008]:Error:unexpected attribute "svg:viewbox"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,12532]:Error:unexpected attribute "text:display-levels"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,31163]:Error:attribute "style:name" has a bad value: "" does not satisfy the "NCName" type
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,40109]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,42874]:Error:unexpected attribute "svg:viewbox"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,43199]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,44396]:Error:unexpected attribute "svg:viewbox"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,45322]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,46181]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,47370]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,48886]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,51026]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,52691]:Error:unexpected attribute "svg:viewbox"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,53039]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,53832]:Error:unexpected attribute "svg:viewbox"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,55127]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,56404]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,58030]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,58970]:Error:unexpected attribute "draw:mirror-horizontal"
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,60176]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,60384]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt/content.xml[2,60625]:Error:element "text:p" was found where no element may occur
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt:Info:validation errors found
upload:///23_ebXML System Overview_modified.odt:Info:Generator: TextMaker


More errors

And for the File sent to the support team :
From OpenOffice :
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/styles.xml[2,1462]:Error:element "office:document-styles" is missing "version" attribute
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/styles.xml[2,4949]:Error:unexpected attribute "textmaker:pgf-auto-space-before"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/styles.xml[2,20984]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/styles.xml[2,21858]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,3214]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,4263]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,5596]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,6759]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,7922]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,9112]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,10275]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,11442]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,12611]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,13807]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,14976]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,16145]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,17314]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,18312]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,19652]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,21486]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,22655]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,23824]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,24993]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,25991]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,27331]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,28994]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,29940]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,31170]:Error:unexpected attribute "style:keep-together"
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,70067]:Error:attribute "text:start-value" has a bad value: "-1" does not satisfy the "nonNegativeInteger" type
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,117093]:Error:attribute "text:start-value" has a bad value: "-1" does not satisfy the "nonNegativeInteger" type
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,147318]:Error:attribute "text:start-value" has a bad value: "-1" does not satisfy the "nonNegativeInteger" type
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt/content.xml[2,176684]:Error:attribute "text:start-value" has a bad value: "-1" does not satisfy the "nonNegativeInteger" type
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt:Info:validation errors found
upload:///DocumentReference_OO.odt:Info:Generator: OpenOffice.org/3.2$Win32 OpenOffice.org_project/320m18$Build-9502


From TextMaker :
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,15878]:Error:unexpected attribute "text:display-levels"
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,136648]:Error:element "text:table-of-content" is missing "name" attribute
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,165845]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,166398]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,169255]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,211552]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,212922]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,241322]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,241868]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,247967]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,250263]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,268063]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt/content.xml[2,268835]:Error:attribute "text:style-name" has a bad value
upload:///DocumentReference.odt:Info:validation errors found
upload:///DocumentReference.odt:Info:Generator: TextMaker



Which version of the ODF specification TextMaker use ?
Do you have a plan to comply strictly to the ODF Validator in the next Service Pack or future major release ?

Regards,

Arnaud

sven-l
SoftMaker Team
SoftMaker Team
Posts: 5991
Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2008 7:26 am
Location: Nuremberg
Contact:

Re: TextMaker better than OpenOffice for ODT compliance ?

Postby sven-l » Mon Aug 30, 2010 9:46 am

ArnaudK wrote:Which version of the ODF specification TextMaker use ?
Do you have a plan to comply strictly to the ODF Validator in the next Service Pack or future major release ?


Arnaud,

I referred your questions to our developers and will answer here as soon as I have more information.
Sven Leßmann
SoftMaker Software GmbH

sven-l
SoftMaker Team
SoftMaker Team
Posts: 5991
Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2008 7:26 am
Location: Nuremberg
Contact:

Re: TextMaker better than OpenOffice for ODT compliance ?

Postby sven-l » Tue Aug 31, 2010 10:03 am

Dear Arnaud,

we currently support ODF 1.1. We are still waiting for the final version of ODF 1.2.
Sven Leßmann
SoftMaker Software GmbH


Return to “TextMaker 2010 for Linux”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest